Derrick Rose or Kirk Hinrich???

Who's better out of the two. I know you really can't compare college and nba, but I think rose would be a bigger upgrade. Kirk can't rebound for sh*t. I know kirk is a better shooter, but rose is a solid one. ROSE IS WAY BETTER. Tell me what you think.

Derrick Rose or Kirk Hinrich???
Rose is definitely the better player with a much better upside, I dont see Hinrich getting much better than he already is. Hinrich is a decent point guard but Rose has the potential to be great. Better leader, and definitely willing to take over a game at the end as we saw in the NCAA tournament. But I think the Bulls will take Beasley because they already have enough guards and really need an inside presence.
Reply:Rose definitely has the upside because he's young, mobile, and most all a bona fide scorer. However, Hinrich is your established prototypical point guard. With Hinrich, you know what you're getting: 15 points, 7 dimes, 3 %26amp; half boards, and a steal per game almost. I know Hinrich's been stuggling and has had somehwat of a slump of late, but if the Bulls were to pick Beasley #1. Then Hinrich's numbers would jump. Oh and last time I checked, point guards don't get that many rebounds.
Reply:Rose for sure. If the Bulls do take Rose though, I don't think Hinrich is the one out the door, I think it's Gordon. The Bulls just recently resigned Hinrich to another deal and when they tried to resign Gordon he refused. They obviously don't want to lose Gordon to FA so they'll trade him and try and get something in return.
Reply:The only way Chicago will do this is if they can work out a trade for Hinrich and get equal compensation in return for Kirk. Otherwise I doubt they'll draft another point guard.
Reply:Derrick Rose. Stronger and quicker. Rose isn't as a good a shooter, but can more others around him better.
Reply:Rose. He's a better all-around player and leader than Hinrich. Kirk can provide Rose competent backup, though
Reply:rose very soon